Served naked or with one of our 16 sauces All flats or drummies-$2.25 extra
3 strips served with a side of sauce
Crispy pickle chips with a side of ranch
Served with cocktail sauce Add Cajun seasoning/ Cajun ranch- $1.25 each
Fried and served with ranch
6 poppers per order
Lightly beer battered
6 sticks per ordered and served with marinara
Served with wasabi ranch
6 egg rolls served with sweet & sour or soy sauce
Fresh livers and gizzards hand breaded and deep fried. Available as a full 1lb order or 1/2 order of each or a single 1/2 order
Miniature burger served with pickle
Miniature bbq sandwich served with pickle
Make it Buffalo for $1 extra
4 mozzarella sticks, 8 breaded mushrooms & 8 onion rings. No substitutions.
Sliced potatoes fried to a golden crisp topped with bacon, cheese sauce, shredded cheddar cheese and chives. Served with sour cream Add BBQ pork- $3 extra
Loaded with cheese sauce and shredded cheese
Cup $4 Bowl $5 Make it a combo with grilled cheese for $4 extra
Grilled or breaded chicken with your choice of dressing. Make it Buffalo for $.50
Grilled chicken, pecans, strawberries and feta cheese. Served with balsamic vinaigrette.
Turkey, ham, lettuce, onion, tomato, croutons and shredded cheese. With your choice of dressing.
Grilled seasoned chicken, lettuce, black beans, corn, southwestern seasoning and tri-colored tortilla chips.
Grilled chicken, lettuce, walnuts, craisins, pineapple and feta cheese. Served with raspberry vinaigrette.
Lettuce, tomato, onion, shredded cheese and croutons with your choice of dressing
Ranch Honey mustard Italian French Thousand island Poppy seas Caesar Raspberry vinaigrette Blue cheese Balsamic vinaigrette
Seasoned and grilled just the way you want it. Add a slice of American cheese for $0.75
Your choice of hamburger or chicken and served with grilled onions and 1000 island dressing
Your choice of grilled or breaded chicken Add Buffalo sauce for $0.75 Make it jerk chicken for $1
Grilled chicken breast served with Swiss cheese, grilled onion, tomato, bacon and ranch dressing.
1/2 lb burger, bacon, crunchy jalapeño crisps, jalapeño jelly and pepper jack cheese.
House cut and pounded out. Served grilled or hand breaded and fried
Smoked pulled pork smothered in our flavorful bbq sauce. Served with pickles.
Served on wheat or white toast.
1/2 lb burger topped with popcorn shrimp, Cajun ranch, cheddar Jack cheese and shredded lettuce.
Served with melted mozzarella cheese on a hoagie bun
All shoes are served with fried and topped with our homemade cheese sauce Choose from: hamburger, chicken strips, grilled chicken, ham, turkey, bbq pork $1 extra- Buffalo chicken, loose meat $1.50 extra- pork tenderloin, supreme (grilled peppers, onion, and tomatoes) $2.50 extra for deluxe (supreme+chili)
Popcorn shrimp. Add Cajun seasoning for $1
Served with your choice of dipping sauce
Served with 6 wings in your choice of sauce
8 fan tailed shrimp deep fried golden brown
Grilled or breaded chicken with lettuce, shredded cheese and your choice of sauce. Served with salad or chips. Substitute French fries for $1.50
Loose hamburger, shredded lettuce, shredded cheddar cheese, onions, pickles and our special sauce. Served with salad or chips. Substitute French fries for $1.50
Grilled chicken, black olives, feta cheese, tomatoes and vinegar and oil dressing. Served with salad or chips. Substitute French fries for $1.50
Grilled seasoned chicken, lettuce, black beans, corn, southwestern seasoning, tri-colored chips and Cajun ranch. Served with salad or chips. Substitute French fries for $1.50
8.50- 1/4 chicken 10.50- 1/2 chicken Served with mashed potatoes, gravy, veggie and garlic bread.
Walleye $10 Shrimp $10.50 (During Lent Cod $10.50) All served with fries and slaw.
Hamburger pony shoes $8.50
Hamburger, fries and a fountain drink
Coke, Diet Coke, sprite, dr. Pepper, Mello Yello, lemonade, milk, fresh brewed ice tea
From a reviewer’s perspective, Caddyshack Sports Bar & Grill offers a menu that comfortably balances classic bar favorites with hearty comfort food. The appetizer selection is a strong way to start, featuring crowd-pleasers like 12 Wings, Chicken Strips, Fried Pickle Chips, Popcorn Shrimp, and Breaded Mushrooms, all ideal for sharing while watching a game. The salad lineup adds variety, with options such as Chicken Salad, Strawberry Summer Salad, Chef Salad, Southwestern Salad, and Chicken Teriyaki Salad, giving diners lighter choices without sacrificing flavor. For those craving something more substantial, the sandwich section stands out with the 1/2lb Charbroiled Burger, Patty Melt, Chicken Breast Sandwich, Bacon Chicken Ranch Sandwiche, and the flavorful Sweet Heat Burger. Local comfort-food fans will appreciate the signature Ponyshoe-Horseshoe, while the dinner baskets, including the Shrimp Dinner Basket, Chicken Strip Basket, Wing Basket, and Butterfly Shrimp, deliver satisfying portions. The wrap selection, featuring the Chicken Wrap, Shack Wrap, Mediterranean Wrap, and Southwestern Crunch Wrap, provides additional variety for lunch or dinner. Families are also well served thanks to a dedicated kids’ menu with favorites like Grilled Cheese with Fries, Cheeseburger and Fries, Kids hamburger ponyshoe, Chicken strips and French Fries, and Kids breaded Chicken Wrap and Fries. Daily specials such as Monday- Mexican Monday, Thursday- Fried Chicken, Friday- Walleye and Shrimp, and Saturday- Pony Special keep the menu fresh and encourage repeat visits. Paired with simple refreshments like Soda, the overall menu delivers a satisfying sports-bar experience with plenty of options for different tastes and appetites.